Whilst scanning some things, I found this interesting PSA in No. 42 of the NBTHK Tōken Bijutsu magazine (November, 1956). Therein, then 49-years-old Satō Kanzan (佐藤寒山, 1907–1987) is warning readers about fake sayagaki of his making the rounds. I thought it might be of interest, so I translated that announcement:
“It seems that I have a bit of a tendency of writing too many sayagaki. I have a bad habit of doing them whenever someone asks, and since my handwriting is easy for others to imitate, I have been seeing a lot of fake sayagaki of mine in various places recently. People have long warned me that there are false sayagaki out there, and to be cautious, but no matter how careful I am, there is no way for me to stop those who forge sayagaki in my name.
This is not about me per se, but it causes great trouble for those who trust me, people who end up buying something without realizing it’s a forgery. For example, I have been told that a certain Mr. Itsutsuji (五辻) boldly wrote a sayagaki in front of a crowd and signed it with “Kanzan.” Apparently, some people who didn’t know better even thought that this Mr. Itsutsuji was actually “me.” While my gō (art name) is registered in the field of art history, unlike a trademark, a gō isn’t something that legally prevents others from using it if they so choose.
In any case, writing big name sayagaki on inferior items is a malicious tactic. I ask that you please not rely solely on sayagaki, but instead carefully examine the blade itself and the signature (mei) before making a purchase. As for me, I will do my best to refrain from writing sayagaki for the time being. Please join me in trying to eliminate these unscrupulous individuals.”
Identity theft is clearly not a novelty in the information society of the Internet age…
Interesting blog post from one of the founders of the NBTHK. I have a hakogaki by Satō Kanzan for a set of menuki I wonder if it is fake. The artwork (menuki) associated with the hakogaki is not signed so I don’t think I should be concerned so much about it. The hakogaki does not unfortunately include a date like some do.
Aloha Marcus Lost Swords of Japan. Everyone knows about the Honjo Masamune, but we always see ko- this and that and wonder…..could it be a lost sword? I think your book on this would sell to more than just I, and maybe lead to ID & recovery. MahaloSteve
Hi MarkusI am leaning towards Awataguchi Yoshimitsu for this months kantei. What are your thoughts?JohnSent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
I would stick with that, yes.
Thx, any update on the Yamashiro book yet. I think I’ve read the yanato 5 times.Joh Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
No updates yet, I’m afraid. But should get one soon on Yamashiro as I am about halfway through with the first Bizen volume.